Topps and Panini showcase minor stars in major ways
It’s common for different companies to attempt to produce the same product with varying levels of success. When it happens with baseball cards, we’ll put them Head to Head to find out which one comes out on top and what room there is for improvement.
Last year, Topps revived its Archives brand as a celebration of past card designs and fan favorite players you may have forgotten. This year, Panini countered with Hometown Heroes. The alliterative title alone made it clear that Panini was aiming squarely at the target market for Archives (which itself was known as All-Time Fan Favorites in a past incarnation). The Hometown Signatures insert set is a clear counterpart to Archives’ Fan Favorites Autographs insert set, a collection of on-card autographs from dozens of the game’s lesser stars. Ideally, I would compare the complete offerings of both products, but the Hometown Heroes base set is so unappealing that I haven’t gone anywhere near it. Even the secondary autograph insert sets are fairly boring (and all use sticker autographs, though Archives has gone in that direction as well), so there really isn’t anything worth looking at except for the Hometown Signatures set. And even that may be a bit of a stretch.
Card Design
Luckily, we have plenty of overlap in the Fan Favorites Autographs and Hometown Signatures checklists. Ron Darling is the lone Met common to both sets, so let’s start there. On the Fan Favorites Autographs side, Topps uses classic card designs with new photos and a faded section at the bottom for the signature. Hometown Signatures on the other hand combines geometric shapes in light blue and light green to make, well, that. A chartreuse section at the bottom serves as the signature location. Since Panini lacks a license from MLB Properties, no team names or logos are used, just a “New York” team identifier. Only the 2013 Hometown Heroes logo adds any distinctiveness to the overwhelming blandness of the design. Both feature the newer form of Darling’s signature, which you can get in person on a card of your choice at the Queens Baseball Convention, January 18, 2014 at McFadden’s Citi Field (subtle plug).
This isn’t a showdown so much as it’s a one-sided smackdown. Panini starts out at a disadvantage without team names and logos, but a generic design with the worst possible color combination isn’t helping. On top of that, the blue ink on green background turns the signature blue-black, keeping the main focus of the card from standing out. I haven’t even gotten into how the use of vintage cardboard stock with an unspectacular modern design (I would say “vintage-inspired” if I could figure out the inspiration) makes everything look like a cheap knock-off… The 1986 Topps design isn’t exactly a crowd pleaser, but the execution on modern card stock is flawless. Combine that with the nostalgia of 1986 and you have a clear winner to go along with Panini’s clear loser.
Player Selection
Well, that wasn’t very exciting. Maybe a look at the checklists can even things out. The 2013 Hometown Signatures set weighs in at 93 cards, far more than the 58 cards in the 2013 Fan Favorites Autographs set. While many of the names on the Hometown Signatures list are familiar from the 2012 and 2013 Fan Favorites Autographs sets, there are a few notable exceptions. Among those are the first Pat Tabler autographs I’ve seen and the first Garry Templeton autographs since 2001. In all, 14 former Mets are included, including four as Mets (well, “New York” at least): Darling plus Lenny Dykstra, Darryl Strawberry, and Lee Mazzilli.
Yes, Lee Mazzilli has his first autograph from a company other than Upper Deck and his first autograph card with a player photograph since 2007 in the Hometown Signatures set. It may not be pretty, but it’s something. So what does the Fan Favorites Autographs set have to offer?
Looks like Fan Favorites Autographs takes this one too. Mookie Wilson, Jesse Orosco, Ron Darling, Sid Fernandez, Kevin McReynolds, Howard Johnson, Gregg Jefferies, and Keith Miller are all shown as Mets. Miller’s card is his first autograph card and his first card of any kind since 1995. Another seven former Mets are shown with other teams, including Ray Knight, Bret Saberhagen, Hubie Brooks, and four others in common with Hometown Signatures. The Fan Favorites Autographs set just has more to offer.
Verdict
There’s nothing more to say, Fan Favorites Autographs wins this one easily. When going up against an autograph set with history dating back to 2001 and a formula that has been refined nearly to perfection, you need to bring your A game. Panini used a childish design to appeal to childhood memories and it just didn’t work.
Comments are closed.