Breakin’ 3: Bowman Sterling-y
In case you’ve been living under a rock (or just don’t follow the sports card industry), group breaking is the hottest trend in sports cards. For a (relatively) small fee, collectors who can’t afford the high prices of modern cases can still get a shot at a big hit, provided that they buy into the right slots. Formats vary, but there are opportunities to get a big return on a small investment (or the reverse). I’ve been doing the cost-benefit analysis on the various opportunities I’ve seen and finally found the right mix of return and risk in the year’s final offering from Topps as broken by collector favorite Brent Williams. But before we get to that, let’s take a look at a couple of smaller breaks I tested the waters with earlier in the year.
2012 Panini Prizm
The first break I considered this year was the 2012 Panini Prizm team break from Brent Williams. I decided that it wasn’t worth the risk at the asking price when I would probably walk away with a Lucas Duda autograph as the big hit. Instead, I found a cheap 4-box break to buy into. That should have been good for two base team sets on average, which would include a Matt Harvey Rookie card (because this was a 2012 product). In the end, I got what I was hoping for: one full team set, a second team set minus one card, an extra Ike Davis, and a few inserts.
And of course a Duda auto. There was no getting around that one.
2013 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects
I never really know how to deal with Bowman Draft. Prices for some of the cards that come out of it can be quite high, but the long-term value is highly volatile. Positioned at the end of the base Bowman line, most of the Rookie Cards are duplicates from earlier releases (with new photos), which adds to the confusion. This year, with increased production, decreased numbering on colored refractors, and more variants than ever before, I just bought up base and chrome lots, the base autographs, and a few cheap parallels and left it at that. To make things interesting, I also bid on a few player slots in a 5-case break from RynemCaseBreaks. I ended up with only two, Andrew Church (non-auto only) and Zack Wheeler. With a total cost including shipping of less than $20 and a practically guaranteed 30+ card lot of base/chrome cards for each player, I wasn’t too worried about coming up empty. Because there wasn’t much of a chance at a big return anyway.
I actually watched almost all of the 5-case break live and it was quite entertaining. Some slots came up big while others were big losers. The Bowman Black slot, a bargain at well under $100, was the big winner with both Kris Bryant and Austin Meadows pulled from the 5 cases. That’s over $500 worth of cards for a slot that could have been a total loss. On the Mets side of things, the $20 Andrew Church autograph slot came up big with base, refractor, and orange refractor (#d/25) versions pulled in the break. The $120 Dominic Smith autograph slot on the other hand got just a base autograph (worth about $20).
My slots were not big winners. In addition to the expected base and chrome cards, I got four parallels: two Zack Wheeler refractors, a Zack Wheeler ice parallel, and an Andrew Church black wave refractor. Out of all of the base Mets pulled in the break, the best card was a green refractor numbered to 75.
2013 Bowman Sterling
And now, the main event. Bowman Sterling isn’t exactly my favorite product. Released at the end of the year, it usually features a mix of rehashed rookies and draft picks, a less popular second helping of autographs we’ve already seen in more interesting products. Last year, a terribly bland design with refractors that barely looked like refractors did nothing to help the checklist of repeat signers. Prices on the secondary market reflected these problems; I picked up a gold refractor autograph (#d/50) of Kirk Nieuwenhuis for $1.50 plus shipping and a black refractor autograph (#d/25) of Kevin Plawecki for about $10 more. The Bowman Black autographs had some decent value, but the massive chipping that plagued thick Topps autographs in 2012 caused them to lose some of their appeal. Sterling needed a revamp to justify taking a slot in the Topps lineup.
2013 Bowman Sterling is a completely different product from its 2012 incarnation. Sure, the basics are still the same: 3 autographs per pack, 18 total autographs per box, dual sticker autographs, Bowman Black autographs numbered to 25, etc. This time though, the autographs are in portrait orientation (typically more highly desired than landscape) and green, ruby, and orange refractor parallels fill the space between refractors and gold refractors. Most Rookie Card autographs are, unfortunately, on stickers, but the product delivers where it counts: prospect autographs. 2013 draft picks Dominic Smith and Andrew Church return after Bowman Draft, but joining them are Noah Syndergaard with his first Mets autographs and L.J. Mazzilli (fan favorite Lee Mazzilli’s son) with his first certified autograph cards. Add in some Zack Wheeler sticker autographs and you have a solid Mets checklist with a few must-haves for any serious Mets collector.
Shortly after the checklist was released, Brent Williams announced the possibility of a team-based group break of Bowman Sterling on launch day. With 106 rookie/prospect autographs in 2013 Bowman Sterling and 144 total autographs in an 8-box case, the odds of getting all of a team’s base autographs are pretty good. A quick calculation put the over/under of the value of the Mets slot at $90. For the right price, this would be a great break to get in on. Which meant that I probably wasn’t the only Mets fan who would be after this slot.
Two days later, Brent Williams announced that the Bowman Sterling break was on. I was catching up on Twitter while waiting in line at the post office to mail out recent auction sales. And I was a couple of hours behind on my tweets. Skipping to the top, I saw that the price breakdown had just been posted. The Mets slot was priced at $90, right on my estimated cost. At that price, even getting just the base Mets autographs wouldn’t be a bad deal, especially with them all in one package sent the day after launch. There was a chance of getting less, but there was also a decent chance of getting some nice bonuses. 20 minutes after the announcement, I claimed the Mets slot without hesitation. And then I waited two long days for the break to begin.
2013 Bowman Sterling 8-Box Case Break – brentandbecca
I tried to keep my expectations in check. All I wanted were the five base Mets autographs, one of the base Mets cards, and something extra. Unfortunately, I missed the start of the break and came in about halfway through. Among all of the Pirates, Philies, and Yankees autographs, I saw only a Noah Syndergaard base card and two L.J. Mazzilli base autographs. From what I heard, I had missed a pair of Andrew Church base autographs and a Dominic Smith green refractor autograph. That still left me three base autographs short of my goal as the break entered its final minutes. And then the rest of them started hitting one after another. The base Dominic Smith auto and a green refractor Zack Wheeler auto came up at the end of box number 7. Box number 8 held the final two base autos, Syndergaard and Wheeler. And with that, this break had exceeded my expectations.
And that’s it. Nothing huge, but everything I wanted. I also had a chance at both The Duel inserts featuring Mets, but I lost out on both of them to the other team featured on the card. Now I’m just waiting for the post office to deliver the cards.
Comments are closed.